| Name | City/State | Grade | School | AA or HM | Rank |
| Kevin Coogan** | Delran, NJ | 12 | Holy Cross High School | AA | 1 |
| Thatcher Carr | Shaker Hts., OH | 12 | University School | AA | 2 |
| Matt Bricker | Winter Park, FL | 10 | Lake Highland Preparatory | AA | 3 |
| Anthony Holt | Detroit, MI | 10 | Cranbrook Kingswood High School | AA | 4 |
| Scott Koenig | Perrysburg, OH | 12 | St. Francis de Sales | AA | 5 |
| Andrew Maggio | Cincinnati, OH | 12 | St. Xavier High School | AA | 6 |
| Michael Sullivan | Shamong, NJ | 11 | Holy Cross High School | AA | 7 |
| Colby Carter | Falls Church, VA | 10 | Paul VI High School | AA | 8 |
| Palmer Lee | Gold River, CA | 10 | Jesuit High School | AA | 9 |
| Gary Banks | San Jose, CA | 11 | Valley Christian High School | AA | 10 |
| Adam Peterson | Los Altos, CA | 10 | Saint Francis High School | AA | 11 |
| Thomas Crahan | Louisville, KY | 11 | St. Xavier High School | HM | 12 |
| Stewart Smith | Chattanooga, TN | 10 | Baylor School | HM | 13 |
| Blake Lyons | Woodbridge, CT | 10 | Hopkins School | HM | 14 |