| 2002-2003 NISCA Girls Independent High School Academic All-America | |||||
| Athlete | Activity | School | City | State | |
| Nicole | Alicino | Swim | North Brunswick Township High School | North Brunswick | NJ |
| Tricia | Beckman | Swim | Archbishop Alter High School | Kettering | OH |
| Susan J. | Bihler | Swim | Detroit Country Day School | Beverly Hills | MI |
| Lauren | Boris | Polo | Villa Maria Academy | Erie | PA |
| Eileen | Boyle | Polo | Saint Ignatius College Prep | Chicago | IL |
| Kelly | Bradbury | Swim | Knoxville Catholic High School | Knoxville | TN |
| Marianne | Bradford | Dive | Roncalli High School | Indianapolis | IN |
| Kristin | Bresnahan | Swim | Mary Institute Country Day School | St. Louis | MO |
| Sarah | Buchanan | Swim | The Meadows School | Las Vegas | NV |
| Sylvia | Cardim | Polo | Gulliver Preparatory School | Pinecrest | FL |
| Kirsten | Cartoski | Swim | Our Lady of Mercy Catholic High School | Fairburn | GA |
| Julia | Cheuk | Swim | Metairie Park Country Day School | Metairie | LA |
| Sarah | Chuzi | Swim | The Madeira School | McLean | VA |
| Elizabeth | Clark | Polo | Sacred Heart Preparatory School | Atherton | CA |
| Kristin | Clark | Swim | Bishop Hoban High School | Wilkes Barre | PA |
| Jessica | Connors | Swim | Divine Savior Holy Angels High School | Milwaukee | WI |
| Krista | Corabi | Swim | Catholic Central High School | Steubenville | OH |
| Katherine | Dann | Swim | Girls Preparatory School | Chattanooga | TN |
| Patricia | De Groot | Swim | Marist School | Atlanta | GA |
| Diane | Duncheskie | Swim | Gwynedd Mercy Academy | Gwynedd Valley | PA |
| Julia | Edwards | Polo | Menlo School | Atherton | CA |
| Libby | Felix | Swim/Polo | Villa Maria Academy | Erie | PA |
| Adrienne | Fischer | Swim/Polo | Villa Maria Academy | Erie | PA |
| Colleen | Fitzharris | Swim | Seattle Preparatory School | Seattle | WA |
| Elizabeth | Foglesong | Dive | Phoenix Country Day School | Paradise Valley | AZ |
| Katherine | Foley | Swim | Bishop Watterson High School | Columbus | OH |
| Rebeca | Foley | Swim | Divine Savior Holy Angels High School | Milwaukee | WI |
| Sara | Freeman | Swim | Marist School | Atlanta | GA |
| Allie | Freshman | Swim/Polo | Gulliver Preparatory School | Pinecrest | FL |
| Amy | Gardner | Swim/Polo | Menlo School | Atherton | CA |
| Elizabeth | Garlow | Swim | Mercy High School | Farmington Hills | MI |
| Margaret | Gentry | Swim | Norfolk Academy | Norfolk | VA |
| Danielle | Graham | Swim/Polo | Fenwick High School | Oak Park | IL |
| Elena | Griego | Swim | St. Pius X High School | Albuquerque | NM |
| Dana | Gulbransen | Swim/Polo | University of San Diego High School | San Diego | CA |
| Catherine | Healy | Swim | Saint Ignatius College Prep. | Chicago | IL |
| Colleen | Heller | Swim/Polo | Villa Maria Academy | Erie | PA |
| Kelly | Hishta | Swim | Pace Academy | Atlanta | GA |
| Emily | Howell | Swim | Ursuline Academy | Cincinnati | OH |
| Sara | Huneke | Swim | Cincinnati Country Day School | Cincinnati | OH |
| Ellen | Johnson | Swim | Notre Dame Academy | Toledo | OH |
| Jennifer | Kaplan | Swim/Polo | Menlo School | Atherton | CA |
| Raquel | Kellert | Swim | Trinity | New York | NY |
| Caitlin | Kelly | Swim | Mercy High School | Farmington Hills | MI |
| Sarah | Kloecker | Swim/Polo | Villa Maria Academy | Erie | PA |
| Jennifer | Kornfield | Swim | Northeast Christian Academy | Kingwood | TX |
| Holly | Kovacs | Swim | Holy Innocents' Episcopal School | Atlanta | GA |
| Bridget | Koza | Swim | Union Catholic High School | Scotch Plains | NJ |
| Katherine | Krummen | Swim | Bishop Watterson High School | Columbus | OH |
| Kelley | Lang | Swim | Father Lopez High School | Daytona Beach | FL |
| Honor | Lawler | Swim | St. Philip Catholic Central High School | Battle Creek | MI |
| Susan | Lee | Polo | Menlo High School | Atherton | CA |
| Rebecca | Levin | Swim | Hopkins School | New Haven | CT |
| Audrey | Light | Swim | Nouvel Catholic Central High School | Saginaw | MI |
| Sarah | Loveland | Swim | Bishop Watterson High School | Columbus | OH |
| Margaret | Marrer | Swim | Lansdale CAtholic High School | Lansdale | PA |
| Mary | Mason | Swim/Polo | Saint Ignatius College Prep | Chicago | IL |
| Moira | McAllister | Swim | Our Lady of Good Counsel High School | Wheaton | MD |
| Kathleen | McCormick | Swim/Polo | Villa Maria Academy | Erie | PA |
| Sarah | McCue | Swim/Polo | The Lawrenceville School | Lawrenceville | NJ |
| Katie | Meister | Dive | McCauley High School | Cincinnati | OH |
| Louise | Minarcik | Swim/Polo | Villa Maria Academy | Erie | PA |
| Marie-Josee | Mont-Reynaud | Swim | Menlo School | Atherton | CA |
| Tara | Mullen | Swim/Polo | Villa Maria Academy | Erie | PA |
| Elizabeth | Mullin | Swim | Trinity School | New York | NY |
| Michelle | Nelson | Swim | Xavier College Preparatory | Phoenix | AZ |
| Julie | Neumann | Swim | St. Joseph's Academy | Baton Rouge | LA |
| Emily | Oberjohn | Swim | Notre Dame Academy | Park Hills | KY |
| Eloise | Page | Swim | Mercy High School | Farmington Hills | MI |
| Megan | Pavlock | Swim | The Linsly School | Wheeling | WV |
| Amanda | Perryman | Swim | Father Lopez High School | Daytona Beach | FL |
| Erin | Peterson | Swim | Bishop O'Dowd High School | Oakland | CA |
| Connolly | Pigott | Swim | Father Ryan High School | Nashville | TN |
| Ashleigh | Powell | Swim | Toledo Christian School | Toledo | OH |
| Annie | Prescott | Swim | Maclay School | Tallahassee | FL |
| Samantha | Rabban | Swim | Xavier College Preparatory | Phoenix | AZ |
| Emily | Rees | Swim | Xavier College Preparatory | Phoeniz | AZ |
| Molly | Rhodes | Swim | Mary Institute Country Day School | St. Louis | MO |
| Elizabeth | Rollins | Swim | Duchesne Academy-Houston | Houston | TX |
| Bridgette | Schertle | Swim | Notre Dame Preparatory School | Towson | MD |
| Katherine | Schlesinger | Swim | The Kincaid School | Houston | TX |
| Katie | Siegal | Swim | Hutchison School | Memphis | TN |
| Brigid | Smigiel | Polo | Saint Ignatius College Prep | Chicago | IL |
| Jaqueline | Smith | Swim | Mercy High School | Farmington Hills | MI |
| Mary Helen | Solomon | Swim | Texas High School | Texarkana | TX |
| Diane | Sweeda | Swim | Bishop Hoban High School | Wilkes Barre | PA |
| Kimberley | Sykes | Polo | Menlo School | Atherton | CA |
| Rebecca | Taub | Swim | Hopkins School | New Haven | CT |
| Katherine | Teodosic | Swim | Cranbrook Kingswood High School | Bloomfield Hills | MI |
| Elissa | Test | Swim/Polo | Menlo School | Atherton | CA |
| Kristin | Tremoulis | Swim | Lima Central Catholic High School | Lima | OH |
| Ashley R. | Trock | Swim | Detroit Country Day School | Beverly Hills | MI |
| Anne | Tucker | Swim | Tampa Preparatory School | Tampa | FL |
| Rachel | Walker | Swim | Forest Ridge School | Bellevue | WA |
| Elizabeth | Whiteley | Swim/Polo | Menlo School | Atherton | CA |
| Alexandra | Wilson | Swim | Saint Ignatius College Prep | Chicago | IL |
| Samantha | Wilson | Swim | Trinity | New York | NY |
| Teresa | Wilson | Swim | Deep Valley Christian School | Redwood Valley | CA |
| Allison | York | Swim | Briarcrest Christian School | Memphis | TN |
| Laura | Young | Swim | Heritage Christian School | Indianapolis | IN |